Ports and Bows Blog

A week later: Costa Concordia

POSTED ON January 21, 2012 3:00 AM

The news outlets are capably handling the day-to-day and more immediate happenings about the sinking of the Costa Concordia a week ago. It's hard to believe so much time has passed and still there are so many questions — despite the captain’s admission that he took the ship too close to the rocks and paid the price.

It's interesting that he followed that same route, approved by Costa management a year ago for Island celebrations, and apparently was off course by some 600 feet. Lloyd’s List, a specialist in shipping, said it might have even been closer.

What happens from here?

An international panel of some of the finest investigators, along with the Italian Coast Guard and others, must conduct a thorough investigation. One that covers everything from the training of the crew, the training of the officers, the safety procedures, the integrity of the design and the quality of the materials used.

When that investigation is concluded, I believe it will not only be the captain who is blamed for this tragedy.

The law has to be changed. This idea of holding a safety drill within 24 hours of sailing is archaic — no ship should leave port before that is done — and I notice that some have already responded, insuring that drills will be held before sailing. All ships should have an electronic check in to ensure everyone is in place.

You, the passenger, have to take some responsibility. If you're travelling with children, make sure you have a meeting spot and get to the boats in a hurry. Teens should probably make a deal with their family to meet at the muster station.

Take some time to memorize the route from the lifeboat to your cabin. In an emergency you do not want to come flying out of your cabin and turn the wrong way.

When you consider the numbers, since 2005 there have been 100 million passengers and only 16 lives were lost prior to this accident, so cruising has had an amazing safety record. However, one life lost is one too many.

That ship will be on the rocks for some time and it should serve as a reminder of what can happen if due diligence is not carried out minute by minute, hour by hour.

Having spent many hours on the bridge of cruise ships, I can guarantee there's a lot of captains whose pride is wounded by this event.  What would have happened if this captain had called "Mayday!" the moment the accident happened?

When the Carnival Splendor was without power in the Pacific just over a year ago, it was the captain who did everything right. Honours were bestowed on him and rightly show. He is in command of the ship and his men and women should be ready to act on his direction.

Both black boxes have been found in good shape. This will go a long way to determining what happened that night and whether or not any of the problems are systemic. If not, after the cruise lines examine all their safety features — with teams working seven days a week I would hope — you can e sure any changes will be implemented immediately.

If you are a veteran of cruising and you're sailing in the upcoming week, please let me know if you have noticed any differences.

I will be back Monday with my regular blogs and I will have more on the Costa Concordia as it unfolds.

Have a good weekend.

All for now.

Photo by Max Rossi/ Reuters

10 Comment(s)

Although I agree with you that all people should know where your muster station is and memorize it's location (a little difficult at the beginning of a cruise when you're barely able to find the dining room) I do think, at all costs, you need to use your head.  If you were on the Costa Concordia your muster station might be on the part of the ship IN the water.  Keeping calm, listening to staff members and use your head.  

FOUND YOU IN GAZETTE & LIKED IT. MANY CRUISES SINCE 1933, INCLUDING ROUNDWORLD  CP1936  & 15 HAL SINCE 1996. WOULD WELCOME PHONE CALL 514-482-0906.

I have only been on two cruises but can assure you I felt safe, even in some very rough water on the west coast in September to San Diego. The Captain on that cruise was always in control of the ship and kept the guests updated and off the outside decks and we were made aware that things could escalate at any time. On both cruises we had a safety drill before hitting the open water. One was Celebrity, the other Holland America. I was shocked that the guests of The Costa Concordia had not had a safety drill! Next time I take a cruise I will certainly take it more seriously, and remember some of your points for passengers that are their own responsibility to follow. I will always keep my passport with me and not in the safe, AND a flashlight attached to my purse!

We have cruised many times with Holland America and some times we have had to do the safety drill twice as new passangers have come on board. Always done prior to sailing and attendance taked.

U read an article in the newspaper the other day in which the writer was critical of todays cruise ships.

Toop big he said for safety.

TJop heavy and overcrowded for safety.

In the case of the Costa Condordia I feel that it certainlly wasen't the ships fault - design or otherwise.

Any ship encountering rocks scraping the hull can be in trouble, any ship any size.

It's true that evacuaating a large cruise ship is problamatic but as Ports and Bows points out the safety record of todays cruise lines is very good.

My family and I have cruised 19 times now, once into the edge of a hurricane and we always felt safe.

Muster station drils are essential - and I feel there should be a secondary plan if the assigned muster station is unusable.

Hindsight is usually 20-20 and it will take some time for the true facts to be revealed in the case of the Costa Concordia.

To jump to conclusions would be a mistake, to lay early blame an error.

Cruising in my opinion is still the best value for the money and let's have our thoughts with the famalies of those directly affected by the Consta ship that lies on the rocks off the coast of Italy.

When something major goes wrong it is usually due to a cascade effect..one thing goes wrong, then another, another and so on.

I am sure there wil lbe valuable lessons learned from this disaster which could help avoid trouble in the future.

We cruised with Costa last year,from the R.D.We had never seen such a disorganized ship.Getting off the boat,either for an excursion or just a walk on shore,was an horrendous experience.The safety drill was done the day before we were getting off:how incredible is that!!!It

was our first trip with Costa and our last.

We have cruised about 10 times. I took the drills no more seriously than the safety warnings given on airplanes.However this incident reveals the risks. The power is out and the ship is black. Its on its side meaning those on the submerged side have to extricate themselves at a 45 degree angle in the dark. Those not in their cabins have to attempt to get their life jackets either from a submerged cabin or an inaccessible cabin because of the list of the ship.And they have to do this on their own intuition because the crew is concealing from them the truth of the tragedy.

Moreover the response of Costa/Carnaval/Arison suggests that they couldn't care less what happened to these folks.

This incident will leave many of us wondering just what goes on behind the scenes with these characters.

I have cruised 4 times, one Carnival 2 HAL.  I am watching very closely what the company is going to do for those passengers.  I for one will not give this company any more of my money if the passengers on that unfortunate cruise are treated as badly as they seem to be both at the time of crisis and afterwards.  The mark of this company is going to be made and I for one will be watching before I book another cruise.  I also think that in a crisis on board you have to rely on your own judgement, and not believe the crew telling you everything is fine.  Prepare for the worst, and do pay attention to where all lifeboats and lifejackets are located on board.

Must concur with SJ Kidd we cruise with HAL and have always had a lifeboat drill prior to leaving the dock and attendance was taken.  I have seen passengers taking the drill later if they had missed the first.  Life jackets where worn until lately but no longer as the ties etc. presented a hazard however the crew continues to demonstrate the correct method of donning them.  Children are provided wrist identity tags to ensure they reach the same lifeboat as their parents.

We were on Holland America before Xmas and we're surprised that we did not have to have our life jackets on during the drill and roll call was not done as on our previous H/A cruises.  It will be interesting to see if the line goes back to that practise.  Yes, we will certainly take the drills more seriously now.

Leave a Comment

(required)  
(optional)
(required)  
Add

Search

in

Search Archives by Date